"What sets Top It Off Pizza apart is their attention to detail. Every dish feels intentional.
About Top It Off Pizza
Top It Off Pizza stands out as a beloved pizza destination along Tyler’s bustling South Southeast Loop 323, offering diners an authentic pizza experience that combines quality ingredients with generous portions. This well-established pizzeria has earned its stellar reputation among East Texas locals through consistent service and a commitment to crafting pizzas that satisfy both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike.
The menu showcases a comprehensive selection of handcrafted pizzas featuring both classic combinations and creative specialty pies loaded with fresh toppings. Diners can choose from traditional favorites like pepperoni and sausage or explore more adventurous options with multiple meat combinations and vegetable-packed varieties. The restaurant also offers appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes to round out the dining experience, ensuring something for every appetite.
The interior creates a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere with comfortable booth seating and tables that accommodate both intimate dinners and larger group gatherings. The casual dining environment features warm lighting and a relaxed ambiance that makes it equally suitable for quick weeknight meals or leisurely weekend dinners with friends and family.
Visitors should make Top It Off Pizza a priority when seeking reliable, satisfying comfort food in Tyler. The restaurant excels for family dinners, casual date nights, or any occasion calling for hearty, well-prepared pizza. With its convenient location, consistent quality, and welcoming atmosphere, this pizzeria delivers the kind of dependable dining experience that keeps locals coming back and ensures visitors leave planning their next visit.
Must-Try Dishes
Recommended by locals and visitors
Recent Reviews
This man knows pizza!! the red sauce is hands down best in Tyler. you walk in and are transported to the east coast, you hear the owners accent and know...
Jun 7, 2025
Wow, just wow! This place is legit. All the dough is made from scratch and you can taste the difference! The restaurant is cute with soft lighting and the...
2 months ago
We were in town for a gymnastics meet and wanted something for takeout. I looked up pizza places close to our hotel and this was rated the highest.. and I...
Mar 9, 2025
