Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club

Family Italian restaurant in Tyler, California

★ 4.4 154 reviews $$ ✨ Family dinner and casual date nights

📍 7916 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX

💬 What Locals Say

The food at Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club speaks for itself. Authentic flavors that keep me coming back.

🍽️ About Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club

Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club stands as a beloved cornerstone of Tyler’s dining scene on South Broadway Avenue, offering an authentic Italian experience that has earned loyal following among East Texas diners. This established restaurant combines the warmth of traditional Italian hospitality with the convenience of a neighborhood location, creating a dining destination that feels both special and accessible to visitors seeking genuine Italian flavors.

The menu at Mario’s showcases classic Italian cuisine alongside American favorites, with hand-tossed pizzas taking center stage alongside traditional pasta dishes and hearty entrees. Diners can expect generous portions of comfort food favorites like chicken parmesan, lasagna, and specialty pizzas crafted with fresh ingredients. The kitchen also offers lighter options including fresh salads and seafood preparations, ensuring something appealing for every palate and appetite.

The restaurant’s interior creates a welcoming atmosphere with its casual yet refined decor that strikes the perfect balance between family-friendly comfort and date-night appeal. Warm lighting and comfortable seating arrangements accommodate both intimate dinners for two and larger family gatherings, while the club atmosphere adds an element of community that makes solo diners feel equally at home.

Mario’s serves as an ideal destination for everything from casual weeknight dinners to special celebrations, offering consistent quality that keeps locals returning while providing visitors with an authentic taste of Tyler’s restaurant culture. The combination of reliable service, generous portions, and reasonable prices makes it particularly appealing for families, couples, and anyone seeking satisfying Italian comfort food in a relaxed East Texas setting.

Must-Try Dishes

Chicken Parmesan
Supreme Pizza
Homemade Lasagna

Recent Reviews

Jill D. ★★★★★

That was by far some of the best Italian food I have had in a very long time. The outside does not seem like a place you would get great Italian food but...

Oct 3, 2025

Christian v. ★★★★★

Absolutely amazing experience every time we visit! It's a must when in Tyler! You would think you stepped back in time!

1 month ago

Cheryl G.

Took my daughter here because the reviews were so good. Sadly I was disappointed with my food. I ordered the chicken Marsala. It came out weird. I have...

2 months ago

154 reviews via Yelp

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I contact Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club? +
Call Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club at (903) 581-2309 for reservations, takeout orders, or to check today's specials. You can also visit in person at 7916 S Broadway Ave.
What kind of food does Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club have? +
Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club serves Italian cuisine in Tyler. Popular dishes include Chicken Parmesan.
Any tips for visiting Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club? +
Insider tip: Call ahead on weekend evenings as this local favorite can get busy, especially during peak dinner hours.

📞 Contact & Reserve

Call Now

💰 Price Guide

$ Budget-friendly, under $15/person
$$ Moderate, $15-30/person
$$$ Upscale, $30-50/person
$$$$ Fine dining, $50+/person

📍 Location

City: Tyler

Address: 7916 S Broadway Ave

✓ Why Choose This Place

  • Highly rated 4.4/5
  • 💰 Affordable $$
  • 👥 Popular choice 154 reviews

✨ Great For

Family dinner and casual date nights

💡 Insider Tip

Call ahead on weekend evenings as this local favorite can get busy, especially during peak dinner hours.

🏷️ Restaurant Vibes

Date Night Family Friendly Cozy Atmosphere Local Favorite

📊 Guest Satisfaction

88%

🏢 Claim This Business

Claim your free listing to update your info and get the verified business badge.

Own this business?
Photo