Sister2sister Cookies

Family Bakeries restaurant in Tyler, California

★ 4.8 48 reviews $$$ ✨ Special occasion treats and thoughtful gifts

📍 135 Shelley Dr, Tyler, TX

💬 What Locals Say

Consistent quality and generous portions. Sister2sister Cookies knows how to do Bakeries right.

🍽️ About Sister2sister Cookies

Sister2sister Cookies stands out as Tyler’s premier artisanal bakery, nestled on Shelley Drive where the aroma of freshly baked goods draws visitors from across East Texas. This charming establishment has earned a devoted following with its commitment to handcrafted cookies and desserts that showcase both classic techniques and creative flavors. The bakery offers an intimate experience where each treat is made with meticulous attention to detail.

The menu at Sister2sister Cookies features an impressive array of gourmet cookies, from traditional chocolate chip and snickerdoodles to more adventurous flavors like lavender shortbread and salted caramel thumbprints. Beyond cookies, the bakery crafts seasonal fruit tarts, decadent brownies, and custom celebration cakes that have become local favorites. Each item showcases premium ingredients and sophisticated flavor combinations that elevate simple desserts into memorable experiences.

The atmosphere inside Sister2sister Cookies strikes a perfect balance between rustic charm and modern elegance. Warm lighting illuminates display cases filled with colorful treats, while comfortable seating areas invite visitors to linger over coffee and conversation. The space feels both welcoming and refined, with touches that reflect the care and passion that goes into every baked good.

Sister2sister Cookies serves as Tyler’s go-to destination for special occasions, thoughtful gifts, or simply treating oneself to exceptional desserts. Whether visitors are celebrating birthdays, hosting dinner parties, or seeking the perfect afternoon pick-me-up, this bakery delivers consistently outstanding results. The combination of quality ingredients, skilled craftsmanship, and genuine hospitality makes every visit feel special.

Must-Try Dishes

Salted Caramel Thumbprints
Lavender Shortbread
Custom Celebration Cakes

Recent Reviews

David R. ★★★★★

Sister2Sister Cookies are the very best! Since moving to Shelley Drive it makes it easier for me to avoid the busy traffic of the old location on...

Aug 30, 2025

Kim H. ★★★★

They moved to a new location. These cookies are fabulous when hot. 6 cookies for 16.02

Jul 17, 2024

Jay K. ★★★★★

My wife was in hospital following surgery and wanted something sweet. Bought a dozen mixed cookies, AMAZING! Pricey, yes but they were amazingly delicious.

Oct 15, 2025

48 reviews via Yelp

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Sister2sister Cookies good? +
Yes! Sister2sister Cookies has a excellent 4.8-star rating based on 48 reviews. Diners consistently praise dishes like Salted Caramel Thumbprints and the overall dining experience.
What should I order at Sister2sister Cookies? +
The must-try dishes at Sister2sister Cookies include Salted Caramel Thumbprints, Lavender Shortbread, Custom Celebration Cakes. The Salted Caramel Thumbprints is particularly popular and consistently praised by diners. First-time visitors should definitely try this signature dish.
How do I contact Sister2sister Cookies? +
Call Sister2sister Cookies at (903) 561-7733 for reservations, takeout orders, or to check today's specials. You can also visit in person at 135 Shelley Dr.

📞 Contact & Reserve

Call Now

💰 Price Guide

$ Budget-friendly, under $15/person
$$ Moderate, $15-30/person
$$$ Upscale, $30-50/person
$$$$ Fine dining, $50+/person

📍 Location

City: Tyler

Address: 135 Shelley Dr

✓ Why Choose This Place

  • Highly rated 4.8/5
  • 🥂 Premium experience $$$

✨ Great For

Special occasion treats and thoughtful gifts

💡 Insider Tip

Call ahead to reserve popular seasonal flavors, as they often sell out by mid-afternoon.

🏷️ Restaurant Vibes

Cozy Atmosphere Family Friendly Local Favorite

📊 Guest Satisfaction

96%

🏢 Claim This Business

Claim your free listing to update your info and get the verified business badge.

Own this business?
Photo