Tyler's pasta scene runs from pizzeria red sauce to a mansion-district wine bar building charcuterie boards instead of noodles. The honest split is between the family-owned Italian rooms that have anchored their corners of town for decades and the newer casual spots competing on price and quick service.
The top picks: Rotolo's Pizzeria, Bruno's | Pizza & Pasta, and New York Pizza & Pasta, with all 7 rooms ranked below.
Compare all 7 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
Thin-crust pepperoni is the order locals compare against the regional chains, and it generally wins on flavor even if not every visit lands the crust as thin as advertised. The all-meat pizza runs a thicker crust than some prefer. Screens on the wall and a counter-service pace make it a game-day stop as much as a dinner one, with pasta a secondary reason to come.
The grinder and the pizza are the standing order for regulars who have been coming back for decades, and the antipasto salad holds up as a fresh, generous starter. Execution reads as inconsistent between dine-in and delivery, with delivery orders drawing complaints about grease that dine-in visits do not. A family-run room on a neighborhood scale, not a special-occasion one.
Daily and Sunday specials set this counter apart from the pizza-first competition, with pasta the dish worth seeking out. Service reads as consistently warm, staff taking time to walk newcomers through the menu rather than rushing the order. It is a lunch-and-quick-dinner room, not a destination for lingering, and the price point keeps it in easy weekday rotation.
New York Pizza & Pasta on South Broadway runs on counter service: order at the register under the overhead menu, and the food comes to the table. Diners describe the room as spotless and the staff as patient with first timers who need a minute with the menu.
Pizza is the reason to come. The crust is thin and buttery with a crisp bottom, the ingredients taste fresh, and the cheese pulls. Pizza by the slice lets newcomers try a few kinds before committing to a whole pie, and the meatball, spinach and Alfredo slice has its fans. On the pasta side, regulars recommend the eggplant parmigiana over any other in town, with chicken Tuscany close behind. Dip the garlic knots in marinara.
Practical notes: lunch is busy, and the slice, salad and drink combo is a popular deal. Gluten free pizza is on the menu. Street parking is sometimes needed at lunch. Check a takeout pizza before leaving, and the staff will fix any mistake.
Insider tip
Lunch is the popular time, and diners sometimes park on the street and walk around to the entrance.
What to order
Pizza by the Slice, Eggplant Parmigiana, Garlic Knots
Spaghetti is the dish diners drive in for, some from 30 miles out, and it reads as comfort food done reliably rather than reinvented. Lasagna and fettuccine alfredo round out a menu built for family tables. The room carries a small-town, family-owned feel rather than a polished one, and it works well for a date or a routine dinner alike.
What to order
Spaghetti, Lasagna, Fettuccine alfredo
3320 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75701 · (903) 595-1184
Osso buco and tiramisu anchor a menu that draws on old-school technique, with live music some nights adding to the occasion feel. Service has drawn consistent praise for the host, server, and singer working together on busy evenings. The building itself gives no hint from outside of the kitchen inside, and a pending ownership change with no named successor is worth knowing before booking.
Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue looks plain from the outside, and diners keep saying the inside surprises them. The walls are covered in photos of old movie actors, from Sophia Loren to Laurel and Hardy, and a live singer works through old Italian favorites beside a small dance floor at the bar. Couples dance, birthday tables get a song, and the welcome at the door feels like old friends meeting.
The kitchen holds up its end. The Venetian Chicken comes tender and juicy with mushrooms and sautéed vegetables. The lasagna carries Italian sausage with balanced heat, and the Tuscany Platter puts several dishes on one plate for the undecided. Start with fried ravioli, and expect warm bread with garlic in olive oil before anything else arrives.
Practical notes: Mario's is busy most weekends and seating is limited, so a reservation is the safe move. Servers know the wine list, and a carafe of house wine is the value pour. The classic pasta dishes are the most reliable orders.
Insider tip
Mario's stays busy on weekends and seating can be limited, so diners suggest making a reservation.
The bread that opens the meal draws as much attention as anything on the menu, and the cheese ravioli and Caesar salad back it up, though portions on the ravioli run small for the price. Egg drop soup with spinach and parmesan is an unexpected but praised option. It is a family room built for entrees that satisfy rather than surprise.
Bella Italian Cafe is on FM 2493, out toward Flint, and diners send friends here for one dish in particular: the lobster ravioli. It is rich and tasty, and people who order it once tend to order it again, along with the veal dishes, which use real veal rather than a patty.
Start with the Shrimp Cognac, jumbo shrimp sautéed in a cognac cream sauce. Servers suggest soaking the garlic bread in the sauce, and some diners take extra sauce home. The garlic knots are made fresh and soft, and the Bella salad is a regular order, sometimes topped with grilled salmon. Save room for cannoli or tiramisu, the two desserts diners name.
Practical notes: Sunday lunch is a habit for regulars, and a reservation means little or no wait. Large parties have been seated promptly when they booked ahead. At lunch the ravioli portion runs on the smaller side, so add a starter for a hungry table.
Insider tip
A reservation means little or no wait, and larger groups have been seated promptly when they booked ahead.
What to order
Shrimp Cognac, Lobster Ravioli, Cannoli
HoursMon:ClosedTue - Thu:11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat:11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun:11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
The charcuterie board is the reason to come, built on cured meats, cheeses, fruit, and dips presented with real care, and it travels well for delivery orders too. The wine list is the other half of the draw for a date-night crowd. Service has been uneven on reservation nights, with front-of-house sometimes unprepared for parties who booked ahead.
Villaggio Del Vino on Old Bullard Road is built around wine: an electronic wine list, a sommelier, wine dinners and a Wednesday wine night. The room looks formal, but diners say there is no need to dress up, and it is quiet enough for real conversation. Two patios add outdoor seating, sometimes with singers.
The brick oven pizzas lead the menu, and the prosciutto and fig pizza is the one diners order most, salty and sweet together. The pistachio crusted salmon over saffron orzo or risotto is the favorite main, the butternut squash ravioli is brimming with flavor, and the crab and avocado dip is a family staple for some regulars. Tuxedo cake and crème brûlée close the meal.
Practical notes: lunch is calm and unhurried, and brunch is served on Saturdays. Large groups and busy nights can slow the kitchen, so plan extra time for a party or a celebration dinner.
Insider tip
Lunch is quiet and relaxed, and diners say dressing up is not needed despite the polished room.
What to order
Prosciutto and Fig Pizza, Pistachio Crusted Salmon, Butternut Squash Ravioli
HoursMon - Thu:11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat:11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun:10:30 AM - 8:00 PM
Address4803 Old Bullard Rd, Ste 102 Tyler, TX 75703
Salty prosciutto and cheese against sweet fig preserves on a brick oven crust, often shared with the house salad.
Pistachio Crusted Salmon
Cooked just right and served over saffron orzo or risotto, and diners name it as their favorite entree.
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Diners describe it as brimming with flavor, and the butternut squash pasta draws the same praise.
Pasta questions, answered.
What is the best Italian restaurant near me in Tyler?
It depends on the corridor. South Broadway and the neighborhood spots each have their own regulars, and this guide ranks them by Insider Score, which reflects the pattern across the public review record. No restaurant pays to be listed.
Which Tyler pasta spot is best for a special occasion?
Mario's Italian Restaurant is the closest thing to an occasion room on this list, with live music and old-school technique behind dishes like osso buco. Villaggio Del Vino works for a date-night wine pairing rather than a full pasta dinner.
Where can I get good pizza and pasta on a budget in Tyler?
New York Pizza & Pasta and Bruno's both sit at the lower price tier and run daily specials. Rotolo's Pizzeria fits the same casual, wallet-friendly category with a sports-bar atmosphere.
Are these rankings paid placements?
No. Every restaurant on this list is ranked by its Insider Score, based on the public review record. No restaurant pays for inclusion or position on Tyler Insider.
The data first, then the verdict
We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →
Annette covers the rooms Tyler dresses up for: the steakhouses, the long-standing Italian kitchens, the tables downtown and out along the old highway. Her guides start with the review record and end with a reason to book.
A new place to try.
The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.