Andy’s Frozen Custard

Andy’s Frozen Custard brings a beloved Midwest tradition to Tyler’s South Broadway Avenue, offering visitors an authentic frozen custard experience that stands apart from typical ice cream shops. This cheerful establishment specializes in fresh frozen custard made throughout the day, creating a creamy, dense dessert that’s richer and smoother than conventional ice cream. The location draws families, couples, and dessert enthusiasts who appreciate the difference that fresh-made custard brings to their sweet treats.

The menu centers around Andy’s signature frozen custard, available in vanilla and chocolate daily, plus rotating specialty flavors that change regularly. Visitors can enjoy their custard in cups, cones, or blended into thick concrete mixers loaded with mix-ins like candy, cookies, and fresh fruit. The restaurant also serves frozen custard sundaes, floats, and malts, all made with the same premium custard base that sets Andy’s apart from other frozen dessert establishments.

The atmosphere maintains a clean, bright, and welcoming environment typical of quality frozen custard shops, with colorful signage and efficient counter service that keeps lines moving smoothly. Large windows provide natural light during daytime visits, while the streamlined ordering system ensures quick service even during busy evening hours. The space accommodates both quick grab-and-go visits and leisurely dessert experiences.

Andy’s Frozen Custard serves as the perfect destination for after-dinner treats, family outings, or anyone seeking a premium frozen dessert experience in Tyler. The restaurant’s commitment to making fresh custard daily creates a product that’s noticeably superior to mass-produced alternatives, making it worth the visit for special celebrations, casual date nights, or simply satisfying a craving for exceptional frozen custard.