"The food at Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club speaks for itself. Authentic flavors that keep me coming back.
About Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club
Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club brings authentic Italian flavors to South Broadway Avenue, establishing itself as a beloved dining destination in Tyler’s bustling restaurant scene. This family-owned establishment combines traditional Italian hospitality with the warmth of East Texas charm, creating an inviting space where both locals and visitors can enjoy genuine Italian cuisine in a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere.
The menu showcases classic Italian dishes prepared with fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes. Diners rave about the hand-tossed pizzas with perfectly charred crusts, the rich and creamy chicken alfredo, and the hearty lasagna layered with seasoned ground beef and melted cheese. The kitchen also excels at traditional pasta dishes, from spaghetti carbonara to penne arrabbiata, while the pizza selection ranges from simple margherita to loaded meat lovers’ combinations.
The restaurant’s interior reflects classic Italian trattoria styling with warm lighting, checkered tablecloths, and walls adorned with Italian memorabilia and family photos. Comfortable booth seating and spacious tables accommodate everything from intimate date nights to large family gatherings, while the casual atmosphere encourages diners to linger over their meals and enjoy good conversation.
Mario’s serves as the perfect spot for celebration dinners, family outings, or casual weeknight meals when craving comfort food done right. The generous portion sizes and reasonable prices make it an excellent value for groups, while the consistently prepared dishes ensure a satisfying experience whether visitors are trying it for the first time or returning as regular customers.
Must-Try Dishes
Recommended by locals and visitors
Recent Reviews
That was by far some of the best Italian food I have had in a very long time. The outside does not seem like a place you would get great Italian food but...
Oct 3, 2025
Took my daughter here because the reviews were so good. Sadly I was disappointed with my food. I ordered the chicken Marsala. It came out weird. I have...
1 month ago
The service from Mera was outstanding and the food was spot on. Some of the best Italian we have had in North East Texas. If your in Tyler, you will love...
1 month ago
