Sister2sister Cookies
Sister2sister Cookies
Sister2sister Cookies

Sister2sister Cookies

Family Bakeries restaurant in Tyler, Texas

★ 4.8 48 reviews Bakeries $$$ ✨ Sweet treats and special occasion desserts

"Consistent quality and generous portions. Sister2sister Cookies knows how to do Bakeries right.

About Sister2sister Cookies

Sister2sister Cookies brings artisanal baking to the heart of Tyler, offering visitors a delightful escape into the world of handcrafted desserts. Located on Shelley Drive, this charming bakery has quickly become a beloved destination for those seeking exceptional cookies and sweet treats made with care and attention to detail. The establishment focuses on creating memorable experiences through their commitment to quality ingredients and traditional baking techniques.

The menu showcases an impressive array of freshly baked cookies, from classic chocolate chip and snickerdoodles to seasonal specialties that reflect the flavors of East Texas. Visitors can expect to find creative flavor combinations alongside time-honored favorites, with each cookie baked to perfection. The bakery also offers custom cookie arrangements and gift boxes, making it easy for diners to share their discoveries with friends and family.

The atmosphere at Sister2sister Cookies strikes a perfect balance between cozy neighborhood bakery and modern dessert destination. The inviting interior creates a warm environment where the aroma of fresh-baked goods fills the air, and display cases showcase the day’s selections in an appealing presentation. The space encourages visitors to linger and savor their treats, whether stopping by for a quick pick-me-up or settling in for a leisurely dessert break.

This bakery serves as an ideal destination for celebrations, spontaneous treats, or thoughtful gifts for loved ones. Whether visitors are planning a special occasion, seeking comfort food, or simply indulging in a sweet craving, Sister2sister Cookies delivers an experience that combines quality baking with genuine hospitality that reflects the best of Tyler’s local food scene.

Must-Try Dishes

Recommended by locals and visitors

🍴 Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies
🍴 Snickerdoodles
🍴 Seasonal Sugar Cookies

Recent Reviews

David R. ★★★★★

Sister2Sister Cookies are the very best! Since moving to Shelley Drive it makes it easier for me to avoid the busy traffic of the old location on...

Aug 30, 2025

Jay K. ★★★★★

My wife was in hospital following surgery and wanted something sweet. Bought a dozen mixed cookies, AMAZING! Pricey, yes but they were amazingly delicious.

Oct 15, 2025

Kim H. ★★★★

They moved to a new location. These cookies are fabulous when hot. 6 cookies for 16.02

Jul 17, 2024

48 reviews via

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the phone number for Sister2sister Cookies? +
You can reach Sister2sister Cookies by phone at (903) 561-7733. Calling ahead is recommended for reservations, takeout orders, or to confirm current hours and daily specials.
What type of food does Sister2sister Cookies serve? +
Sister2sister Cookies specializes in Bakeries cuisine, offering a menu of authentic dishes prepared with care. Whether you're a longtime fan of Bakeries food or trying it for the first time, you'll find quality options here in Tyler.
How much does it cost to eat at Sister2sister Cookies? +
Sister2sister Cookies is rated $$$ for pricing, which is upscale at $30-50 per person. This reflects the quality of ingredients, portion sizes, and overall dining experience you can expect when visiting.

Contact & Reserve

Call Now

Hours

Loading...
Mon - Wed10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Thu - Sat10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
SunClosed

Price Guide

$ Budget-friendly, under $15/person
$$ Moderate, $15-30/person
$$$ Upscale, $30-50/person
$$$$ Fine dining, $50+/person

Location

City: Tyler

Phone: (903) 561-7733

Address: 135 Shelley Dr

Why Choose This Place

  • Highly rated 4.8/5
  • 🥂 Premium experience $$$

Great For

Sweet treats and special occasion desserts

Insider Tip

Call ahead to check on seasonal flavors and specialty cookies, as popular varieties tend to sell out quickly during peak hours.

Guest Satisfaction

86%

Own this business?

Claim your free listing to update your info and get the verified business badge.

Own this business?
Photo