Best Italian Restaurants in Tyler, TX (2026)
Tyler Italian restaurants serve up pasta perfection, from creamy fettuccine Alfredo to hearty lasagna and wood-fired pizzas. Find romantic trattorias and family-friendly Italian dining across East Texas.
Local Favorite ★ 4.5 Sal’s Pizza Cafe Italian Restaurant
Henderson
"Call ahead on Friday and Saturday evenings as this popula..."
Homemade Lasagna
Chicken Parmigiana
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.8 Roma Italian Bistro
Jacksonville
"Make reservations for weekend evenings as this popular sp..."
Chicken Parmigiana
Seafood Linguine
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.4 Pazzeria By Pietro’s
Marshall
"Visit on weeknights for a more relaxed dining experience,..."
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.4 Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Club
Tyler
"Visit on weeknight evenings for the most relaxed dining e..."
Chicken Alfredo
Meat Lovers Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Romantic Spot ★ 4.4 Taste of Italy by the Lake
Hawkins
"Request a table by the windows during sunset for the most..."
Lobster Ravioli
Chicken Parmigiana
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.4 Italian Garden
Lindale
"Visit on weekday evenings for the most relaxed dining exp..."
Lasagna Classico
Margherita Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.3 Roma’s Italian Kitchen
Longview
"Visit on Tuesday nights for their special three-course di..."
House-made Lasagna
Fettuccine Alfredo
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.3 Pietro’s Neigborhood Pizzeria & Cafe
Longview
"Visit during weekday lunch hours for quicker service and ..."
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.2 New York Pizza & Pasta
Tyler
"Order the garlic bread as an appetizer - it's made fresh ..."
Meat Lovers Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Family Friendly ★ 4.2 Piada Italian Street Food
Tyler
"Visit during off-peak hours between 2-4 PM for the shorte..."
Diavolo Piada
Carbonara Pasta Bowl
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.3 Benito’s Italian Restaurant
Bullard
"Visit on weeknight evenings for the most relaxed dining e..."
Homemade Lasagna
Grilled Salmon Piccata
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.3 Gino’s Italian Kitchen
Hallsville
"Visit on weekday evenings for a more relaxed dining exper..."
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
+1 more
View Full Profile →