Best Pizza Restaurants in Tyler, TX (2026)
From New York-style slices to wood-fired Neapolitan pies, Tyler pizza shops deliver cheesy satisfaction. Find classic pepperoni, creative specialty pies, and family-friendly dining across East Texas.
Local Favorite ★ 4.6 Top It Off Pizza
Tyler
"Order during weeknight hours to avoid the weekend rush an..."
Supreme Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.8 Pit Stop Pizza
Bullard
"Call ahead during peak dinner hours on weekends to skip t..."
Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.7 Moe’s Pizza
White Oak
"Call ahead during weekend dinner hours as this popular sp..."
Pepperoni Pizza
Supreme Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.4 Switch
Palestine
"Visit on weeknight evenings for the most relaxed dining e..."
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.4 Bella Italian Cafe
Tyler
"Visit during weeknight dinner hours for the most relaxed ..."
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.4 Topp’s Pizza
Tyler
"Call ahead during weekend dinner hours as tables fill up ..."
Supreme Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.4 Pronto Gyros And Pizza
Palestine
"Call ahead during lunch rush hours as the made-to-order i..."
Classic Gyro with Tzatziki
Supreme Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.7 Crust & Crumb Bread
White Oak
"Visit in the morning for the freshest selection of baked ..."
Margherita Pizza
Artisan Bread Loaves
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.2 Jerry’s Pizza
Canton
"Visit during weekdays to avoid the Trade Days crowds, and..."
Hand-tossed Pepperoni Pizza
Italian Sub
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.1 The Page Pub & Pizzeria
Longview
"Visit during happy hour for the best deals on appetizers ..."
Supreme Pizza
Buffalo Wings
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Family Friendly ★ 4.1 Papa Murphy’s Take N Bake Pizza
Tyler
"Order ahead during busy weekends to skip the wait, and re..."
Cowboy Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 3.9 Milano’s Italian Restaurant & Catering
Longview
"Call ahead during weekend dinner hours as the restaurant ..."
Chicken Parmigiana
Meat Lovers Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →