Best Pizza Restaurants in Tyler, TX (2026)
From New York-style slices to wood-fired Neapolitan pies, Tyler pizza shops deliver cheesy satisfaction. Find classic pepperoni, creative specialty pies, and family-friendly dining across East Texas.
Local Favorite ★ 3.9 Doc’s Pizza
Lindale
"Call ahead during Friday and Saturday evenings to avoid t..."
Pepperoni Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 3.8 Milano’s Pizza
Bullard
"Visit during weekday lunch hours for quicker service and ..."
Supreme Pizza
Italian Sub
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 3.7 Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse
Tyler
"Visit during happy hour for the best beer specials, and g..."
Buffalo Wings
Supreme Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 3.6 Pizza Pro Lake Palestine
Chandler
"Call ahead for pickup orders during weekend evenings when..."
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Wings
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 3.6 Rotolo’s Pizzeria
Longview
"Visit during major sporting events for the best atmospher..."
Supreme Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Calzone
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Family Friendly ★ 3.6 Newk’s Eatery
Tyler
"Visit during weekday lunch hours for the quickest service..."
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Ultimate Salad
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 3.6 Pizza King
Longview
"Order ahead during weekend dinner hours as the kitchen ca..."
Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 3.5 Rounders Pizza
Athens
"Visit during weeknight hours for the most relaxed service..."
Pepperoni Pizza
Supreme Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Family Friendly ★ 3.2 Papa Johns Pizza
Tyler
"Order online for faster service and check for current pro..."
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Wings
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Family Friendly ★ 3.3 Marco’s Pizza
Tyler
"Order online for faster pickup during busy dinner hours, ..."
All Meat Supreme Pizza
Italian Sub
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Family Friendly ★ 3.2 Rounder’s Pizza
Tyler
"Visit during weekday evenings for shorter wait times and ..."
Supreme Pizza
Buffalo Wings
+1 more
View Full Profile →