Best Local Favorite Restaurants in Tyler, TX (2026)
These Tyler restaurants have earned devoted followings among East Texas locals who return again and again. Word-of-mouth favorites where regulars are greeted by name and the food never disappoints. When locals recommend a spot, these are the places they mention first.
Local Favorite ★ 4.6 Top It Off Pizza
Tyler
"Order during weeknight hours to avoid the weekend rush an..."
Supreme Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.7 Moe’s Pizza
White Oak
"Call ahead during weekend dinner hours as this popular sp..."
Pepperoni Pizza
Supreme Pizza
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.8 Taqueria Flor de Taxco
Tyler
"Visit during weekday lunch hours for the freshest tortill..."
Carne Asada Tacos
Chiles Rellenos
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Upscale Dining ★ 4.6 Prime 102
Tyler
"Make reservations well in advance for weekend evenings, a..."
Dry-Aged Ribeye
Pan-Seared Filet Mignon
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.7 Great Harvest Bread
Tyler
"Arrive early in the morning for the best selection of fre..."
Honey Whole Wheat Bread
Turkey Avocado Sandwich
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.5 The Foundry Coffee House
Tyler
"Visit during the morning rush between 7-9 AM to experienc..."
Honey Cinnamon Latte
Avocado Toast
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.6 BBQ Express
Marshall
"Arrive before 1 PM on weekends to ensure the best selecti..."
Smoked Brisket Plate
BBQ Ribs
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.5 Sal’s Pizza Cafe Italian Restaurant
Henderson
"Call ahead on Friday and Saturday evenings as this popula..."
Homemade Lasagna
Chicken Parmigiana
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.9 Bryan’s Cheesecake
Tyler
"Call ahead to check on seasonal flavors, as they often se..."
New York Style Cheesecake
Chocolate Turtle Cheesecake
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.8 Best Of Texas Bar-B-Que
Marshall
"Arrive early on weekends as the best cuts of brisket tend..."
Smoked Brisket
Baby Back Ribs
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.5 Bodacious Bar-B-Q
Longview
"Arrive before the dinner rush to ensure the best selectio..."
Smoked Brisket Plate
BBQ Pork Ribs
+1 more
View Full Profile →
Local Favorite ★ 4.6 Ichiban Ramen
Tyler
"Visit during off-peak hours to snag counter seating and w..."
Tonkotsu Ramen
Miso Ramen
+1 more
View Full Profile →