Tyler / Guides / Italian

The best Italian restaurants in Tyler.

Seven Italian rooms in Tyler, Bullard and Lindale, from a live-music supper club to a slice counter, with dishes to order.

The Best Italian Restaurants in Tyler (2026)
7 restaurants · 3 areasCompare the restaurants

Find your Italian restaurant.

Showing all 7 restaurants in ranking order.

About Italian restaurants in Tyler

Italian in the Tyler area runs from a supper club with a live singer to a counter-service pizza shop, with stops in Bullard and Lindale along the way. These seven rooms split between red-sauce comfort, with big platters and garlic rolls, and newer kitchens that make everything from scratch or pour serious wine. Each entry names the three dishes diners order most, so the first visit goes right. We put the rooms in order by how consistently diners praise the food and the evening. Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue leads the list, followed by Benito's Italian Restaurant in Bullard and Italian Garden in Lindale.

The top picks: Mario's Italian Restaurant, Benito's Italian Restaurant, and Italian Garden, with all 7 rooms ranked below.

Compare all 7 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Mario's Italian RestaurantTyler$$8.6Venetian Chicken
02 Benito's Italian RestaurantBullard7.9Fried Zucchini
03 Italian GardenLindale7.8Pasta Sampler
04 Bella Italian Cafe RestaurantTyler7.7Shrimp Cognac
05 LaCascio’s Scratch ItalianLindale7.5Lemon Basil Shrimp
06 New York Pizza & PastaTyler$7.4Pizza by the Slice
07 Villaggio Del VinoTyler$$6.9Prosciutto and Fig Pizza

7 restaurants · In guide order

01

Mario's Italian Restaurant

Italian · Tyler · $$ · № 7 on the ListBack to filters

8.6Insider Score
Mario's Italian RestaurantYelp

Live Music and Lasagna on Broadway

Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue is the evening out of this list, with walls of old film star photos, a small dance floor by the bar and a live singer working through old Italian favorites; music comes up in 27 of 200 diner reviews. The kitchen backs it up. Diners praise the Venetian Chicken with mushrooms, a lasagna with well-spiced Italian sausage, and fried ravioli to start. Warm bread and garlic in olive oil arrive first.

Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue looks plain from the outside, and diners keep saying the inside surprises them. The walls are covered in photos of old movie actors, from Sophia Loren to Laurel and Hardy, and a live singer works through old Italian favorites beside a small dance floor at the bar. Couples dance, birthday tables get a song, and the welcome at the door feels like old friends meeting.

The kitchen holds up its end. The Venetian Chicken comes tender and juicy with mushrooms and sautéed vegetables. The lasagna carries Italian sausage with balanced heat, and the Tuscany Platter puts several dishes on one plate for the undecided. Start with fried ravioli, and expect warm bread with garlic in olive oil before anything else arrives.

Practical notes: Mario's is busy most weekends and seating is limited, so a reservation is the safe move. Servers know the wine list, and a carafe of house wine is the value pour. The classic pasta dishes are the most reliable orders.

Insider tip

Mario's stays busy on weekends and seating can be limited, so diners suggest making a reservation.

What to order

Venetian Chicken, Lasagna, Fried Ravioli

HoursMon - Thu: 5:00 PM - 9:30 PMFri - Sat: 5:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun: Closed
Address7916 S Broadway Ave, Ste 200
Tyler, TX 75703
Call Directions
Map showing Mario's Italian Restaurant© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Venetian Chicken

Tender, juicy chicken with mushrooms and sautu00e9ed vegetables, and diners call it some of the best chicken they have had.

Lasagna

Layers carry Italian sausage with real flavor and balanced heat, and diners pair it with salad and the house bread.

Fried Ravioli

A starter diners call exceptional alongside the calamari, and a good way to open the table before the platters.

02

Benito's Italian Restaurant

Italian · Bullard · № 28 on the ListBack to filters

7.9Insider Score
Benito's Italian RestaurantYelp

Big Plates on Bullard's Main Street

In Bullard, on East Main Street just off Highway 69, Benito's Italian Restaurant feeds people generously. Diners describe portions big enough for two or three, and the dinner bread with herbed olive oil gets its own praise. The New York style pizza has big slices and a crust that is tender and crisp at once. Chicken parmesan, the lasagna and a fried zucchini starter round out the orders regulars repeat. A lunch menu keeps midday prices low.

Benito's Italian Restaurant is on East Main Street in Bullard, a short hop off Highway 69, and it has built its name on generosity. Diners describe portions large enough to feed two or three, and the dinner bread, soft inside and crisp outside, comes with an herbed olive oil that tables fight over. Pace the bread, because the plates are coming.

The New York style pizza is the order for takeout: big slices, a crust both tender and crispy, and a well balanced sauce. Inside, the chicken parmesan is breaded well and cooked through, and the lasagna gets called the best some diners have had. The fried zucchini starter converts people who swear they dislike zucchini, and the pasta trio of cannelloni, lasagna and manicotti covers the classics on one plate.

Practical notes: weekend dinners get crowded and parking runs short, so takeout ordered online is a smart move, and diners report orders ready quickly. The lunch menu is priced well below dinner and draws working crowds at midday.

Insider tip

Takeout ordered online comes out fast, and weekend dinners get crowded with short parking, so ordering ahead helps.

What to order

Fried Zucchini, Chicken Parmesan, NY Style Pizza

HoursDaily: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address475 E Main St, Ste B
Bullard, TX 75757
Call Directions
Map showing Benito's Italian Restaurant© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Fried Zucchini

Battered and fried until crisp outside and tender inside, and it wins over diners who say they dislike zucchini.

Chicken Parmesan

Breaded well and cooked through, diners call it phenomenal and the highlight of the plate.

NY Style Pizza

Big slices with a crust both tender and crispy, and a small pie can stretch across several meals.

03

Italian Garden

Italian · LindaleBack to filters

7.8Insider Score
Italian GardenYelp

Garlic Rolls and BYOB in Lindale

Garlic butter rolls open every meal at Italian Garden on South Main Street in Lindale, and diners talk about them before anything else. Staff tell first timers that nearly everything except the soup is cooked to order, so dishes can be adjusted. The Pasta Sampler puts lasagna, manicotti and cannelloni on one plate, the veal piccata has its regulars, and the cheese tortellini soup earns real praise. It is BYOB, a point raised in 10 of 200 diner reviews, so bring a bottle.

Italian Garden sits on South Main Street in Lindale in a clean, bright building, and the meal starts with warm garlic butter rolls that diners mention before anything else. First timers are told that nearly everything except the soup is cooked to order, so sauce changes and swaps are easy to request.

The Pasta Sampler is the order for the undecided: lasagna, manicotti and cannelloni on one plate, with tossed salad and rolls, and diners say it is plentiful. Veal piccata is a standing order for some families, and veal fans rate it above versions elsewhere. The cheese tortellini soup earns strong praise, the pizza comes thin and crisp, and tiramisu closes things out.

Practical notes: Italian Garden is BYOB, so bring a bottle of wine. The dining room echoes and gets loud when full, and busy times bring a wait. Lunch specials run until late afternoon, and pans of pasta that come with salad and rolls make feeding a crowd easy.

Insider tip

The room gets loud when full and waits run long at busy times, so a late lunch is the calmer visit.

What to order

Pasta Sampler, Veal Piccata, Cheese Tortellini Soup

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Thu: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address2701 S Main St
Lindale, TX 75771
Call Directions
Map showing Italian Garden© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Pasta Sampler

Lasagna, manicotti and cannelloni share one plate with tossed salad and rolls, and diners say it is plentiful.

Veal Piccata

A standing order for some families, and veal fans say this version beats what they find elsewhere.

Cheese Tortellini Soup

Diners call this soup out of this world, and it pairs well with the garlic rolls for dipping.

04

Bella Italian Cafe Restaurant

Pizza · TylerBack to filters

7.7Insider Score
Bella Italian Cafe RestaurantYelp

Lobster Ravioli Off FM 2493

One dish brings people to Bella Italian Cafe on FM 2493, out toward Flint: the lobster ravioli, which diners recommend to friends by name. Start the table with the Shrimp Cognac, jumbo shrimp in a cognac cream sauce that servers suggest soaking up with the garlic bread. Cannoli and tiramisu close the meal, and the garlic knots are made fresh. Sunday lunch is a regular habit for some diners, and the veal dishes use real veal rather than a patty.

Bella Italian Cafe is on FM 2493, out toward Flint, and diners send friends here for one dish in particular: the lobster ravioli. It is rich and tasty, and people who order it once tend to order it again, along with the veal dishes, which use real veal rather than a patty.

Start with the Shrimp Cognac, jumbo shrimp sautéed in a cognac cream sauce. Servers suggest soaking the garlic bread in the sauce, and some diners take extra sauce home. The garlic knots are made fresh and soft, and the Bella salad is a regular order, sometimes topped with grilled salmon. Save room for cannoli or tiramisu, the two desserts diners name.

Practical notes: Sunday lunch is a habit for regulars, and a reservation means little or no wait. Large parties have been seated promptly when they booked ahead. At lunch the ravioli portion runs on the smaller side, so add a starter for a hungry table.

Insider tip

A reservation means little or no wait, and larger groups have been seated promptly when they booked ahead.

What to order

Shrimp Cognac, Lobster Ravioli, Cannoli

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Thu: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address16700 Fm 2493, Ste 1800
Tyler, TX 75703
Call Directions
Map showing Bella Italian Cafe Restaurant© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Shrimp Cognac

Jumbo shrimp come in a cognac cream sauce, and servers suggest dipping the garlic bread right into it.

Lobster Ravioli

The plate people recommend by name, rich and tasty, though the lunch portion runs on the small side.

Cannoli

Diners call these a dessert not to skip, and some order tiramisu alongside for the table.

05

LaCascio’s Scratch Italian

Italian · LindaleBack to filters

7.5Insider Score
LaCascio’s Scratch ItalianYelp

Scratch Cooking on Miranda Lambert Way

Everything from the sauce to the bread is made in house at LaCascio's Scratch Italian on Miranda Lambert Way in Lindale, and servers invite changes to any dish. The room is dressed up with linen napkins, and a gated patio adds outdoor tables. The lemon basil shrimp over fettuccine is the plate diners name most, the crab cakes use large lump crab, and the lasagna is called spot on. Sunday brunch brings lemon ricotta pancakes, and the cheesecake comes with a choice of toppings.

LaCascio's Scratch Italian on Miranda Lambert Way in Lindale lives up to its name: the sauces, meatballs and even the bread are made in house, and servers tell first timers that dishes can be changed on request. The room is polished, with linen napkins and comfortable seating, and a gated patio adds outdoor tables.

The lemon basil shrimp is the plate diners name most, perfectly cooked shrimp in a lemon basil cream sauce over fettuccine. Crab cakes made with large lump crab are the starter to share, alongside the loaded Italian nachos. The lasagna balances sausage and sauce and draws steady praise, and the meatballs come up again and again. Cheesecake arrives with a choice of toppings.

Practical notes: reservations are recommended on weekends and can be made online, and the bar works well for a drink while waiting for a table. Lunch service and Sunday brunch, with lemon ricotta pancakes and blueberry compote, give two more reasons to return.

Insider tip

Weekend reservations are recommended and can be made online, and the bar works well for a drink before the table is ready.

What to order

Lemon Basil Shrimp, Crab Cakes, Lasagna

HoursMon - Thu: 11:00 AM - 8:00 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Address75 Miranda Lambert Way
Lindale, TX 75771
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Lemon Basil Shrimp

Perfectly cooked shrimp in a lemon basil cream sauce over fettuccine, the plate diners keep recommending.

Crab Cakes

Large lump crab, well seasoned and cooked just right, and diners say the starter leaves them craving more.

Lasagna

Diners call it spot on, with sausage and sauce in good balance and nothing frozen about it.

06

New York Pizza & Pasta

Italian · Tyler · $Back to filters

7.4Insider Score
New York Pizza & PastaYelp

Slices and Pasta on South Broadway

Counter service runs New York Pizza & Pasta on South Broadway: order at the register, and the food comes to the table. Pizza appears in 156 of 200 diner reviews, praised for a thin, crisp crust, fresh ingredients and a real cheese pull. Pizza by the slice lets first timers try a few kinds before buying a whole pie, and the lunch slice, salad and drink combo is a favorite deal. The eggplant parmigiana has fans who rank it first in town.

New York Pizza & Pasta on South Broadway runs on counter service: order at the register under the overhead menu, and the food comes to the table. Diners describe the room as spotless and the staff as patient with first timers who need a minute with the menu.

Pizza is the reason to come. The crust is thin and buttery with a crisp bottom, the ingredients taste fresh, and the cheese pulls. Pizza by the slice lets newcomers try a few kinds before committing to a whole pie, and the meatball, spinach and Alfredo slice has its fans. On the pasta side, regulars recommend the eggplant parmigiana over any other in town, with chicken Tuscany close behind. Dip the garlic knots in marinara.

Practical notes: lunch is busy, and the slice, salad and drink combo is a popular deal. Gluten free pizza is on the menu. Street parking is sometimes needed at lunch. Check a takeout pizza before leaving, and the staff will fix any mistake.

Insider tip

Lunch is the popular time, and diners sometimes park on the street and walk around to the entrance.

What to order

Pizza by the Slice, Eggplant Parmigiana, Garlic Knots

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Sun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address1621 South Broadway
Tyler, TX 75701
Call Directions
Map showing New York Pizza & Pasta© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Pizza by the Slice

Thin, buttery crust with a crisp bottom, and buying by the slice lets diners sample before ordering a whole pie.

Eggplant Parmigiana

Fresh and well made, with regulars who recommend it over any other version in town.

Garlic Knots

Soft and garlicky, and diners say they are best dipped in the house marinara.

Advertisement
07

Villaggio Del Vino

Wine Bars · Tyler · $$Back to filters

6.9Insider Score
Villaggio Del VinoYelp

Wine and Brick Oven Pizza

Wine leads at Villaggio Del Vino on Old Bullard Road, with a sommelier, an electronic wine list and wine dinners, plus two patios for cooler weather. The brick oven turns out the prosciutto and fig pizza, the plate diners order most. Pistachio crusted salmon over saffron orzo or risotto is the favorite main, and the butternut squash ravioli has its own fans. Lunch here is calm and unhurried, with room for conversation. Large groups should plan extra time.

Villaggio Del Vino on Old Bullard Road is built around wine: an electronic wine list, a sommelier, wine dinners and a Wednesday wine night. The room looks formal, but diners say there is no need to dress up, and it is quiet enough for real conversation. Two patios add outdoor seating, sometimes with singers.

The brick oven pizzas lead the menu, and the prosciutto and fig pizza is the one diners order most, salty and sweet together. The pistachio crusted salmon over saffron orzo or risotto is the favorite main, the butternut squash ravioli is brimming with flavor, and the crab and avocado dip is a family staple for some regulars. Tuxedo cake and crème brûlée close the meal.

Practical notes: lunch is calm and unhurried, and brunch is served on Saturdays. Large groups and busy nights can slow the kitchen, so plan extra time for a party or a celebration dinner.

Insider tip

Lunch is quiet and relaxed, and diners say dressing up is not needed despite the polished room.

What to order

Prosciutto and Fig Pizza, Pistachio Crusted Salmon, Butternut Squash Ravioli

HoursMon - Thu: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 10:30 AM - 8:00 PM
Address4803 Old Bullard Rd, Ste 102
Tyler, TX 75703
Call Directions
Map showing Villaggio Del Vino© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Prosciutto and Fig Pizza

Salty prosciutto and cheese against sweet fig preserves on a brick oven crust, often shared with the house salad.

Pistachio Crusted Salmon

Cooked just right and served over saffron orzo or risotto, and diners name it as their favorite entree.

Butternut Squash Ravioli

Diners describe it as brimming with flavor, and the butternut squash pasta draws the same praise.

Italian restaurant questions, answered.

What is the best Italian restaurant in Tyler?
Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue tops the list. Diners praise the Venetian Chicken and a lasagna made with well-spiced Italian sausage, and the room adds a live singer and a small dance floor, which makes it the pick for birthdays and date nights. Book ahead on weekends.
Where can I find good Italian food near me in Tyler?
In Tyler, Mario's Italian Restaurant and New York Pizza & Pasta are both on South Broadway, Villaggio Del Vino is on Old Bullard Road, and Bella Italian Cafe is on FM 2493 out toward Flint. North of town, Italian Garden and LaCascio's Scratch Italian are both in Lindale, and Benito's Italian Restaurant is on East Main Street in Bullard.
Which Italian restaurants near Tyler are good for a date night?
Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue has live music and a small dance floor by the bar. LaCascio's Scratch Italian on Miranda Lambert Way in Lindale sets its tables with linen napkins and has a gated patio. Villaggio Del Vino on Old Bullard Road pairs a long wine list with two patios.
Where is the best pizza in Tyler?
New York Pizza & Pasta on South Broadway is the pizza leader, with a thin, crisp crust and pizza sold by the slice. Benito's Italian Restaurant in Bullard serves New York style pies with big slices, and Villaggio Del Vino on Old Bullard Road bakes a prosciutto and fig pizza in its brick oven.

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Annette Holloway
Food Editor

Annette covers the rooms Tyler dresses up for: the steakhouses, the long-standing Italian kitchens, the tables downtown and out along the old highway. Her guides start with the review record and end with a reason to book.

A new place to try.

The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.