Tyler / Guides / Pizza

The best pizza in Tyler: Local Favorites.

Six Tyler area pizza spots, from a stuffed crust in Bullard to New York slices on Loop 323.

Best Pizza in Tyler: Local Favorites (2026)
6 restaurants · 2 areasCompare the restaurants

Find your pizza restaurant.

Showing all 6 restaurants in ranking order.

About pizza in Tyler: Local Favorites

Pizza in Tyler comes in a few clear styles, and this list covers all of them. There are two Italian dining rooms on the south side where a pie shares the table with pasta platters, a carry-out counter on Shiloh Road, a New York slice shop on Loop 323, and a small-town pizza house in Bullard that diners drive out for. Some places fold their slices thin, some load a stuffed crust, and some are best known for the sides. We read the diner record for each one and picked the dishes people order again. Mario's Italian Restaurant leads the list, followed by Pit Stop Pizza in Bullard and Topp's Pizza on Shiloh Road.

The top picks: Mario's Italian Restaurant, Pit Stop Pizza, and Topp's Pizza, with all 6 rooms ranked below.

Compare all 6 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Mario's Italian RestaurantTyler$$8.6Venetian Chicken
02 Pit Stop PizzaBullard$$8.5Stuffed Crust Pizza
03 Topp's PizzaTyler8.2Chicken Alfredo Pizza
04 Top It Off PizzaTyler8.0New York style pizza
05 Bella Italian Cafe RestaurantTyler7.7Shrimp Cognac
06 New York Pizza & PastaTyler$7.4Pizza by the Slice

6 restaurants · In guide order

01

Mario's Italian Restaurant

Italian · Tyler · $$ · № 7 on the ListBack to filters

8.6Insider Score
Mario's Italian RestaurantYelp

Live Music and Lasagna on Broadway

Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue is a full Italian dining room, and the pizza holds its own on a long menu. Diners describe a crust baked with a slight char around the edges and toppings that do not hold back. The table usually fills with house bread and dipping oil, a pasta platter, and the Venetian Chicken. Walls of old Hollywood photos, a dinner singer and a small dance floor make it a favorite for date nights and birthdays.

Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue looks plain from the outside, and diners keep saying the inside surprises them. The walls are covered in photos of old movie actors, from Sophia Loren to Laurel and Hardy, and a live singer works through old Italian favorites beside a small dance floor at the bar. Couples dance, birthday tables get a song, and the welcome at the door feels like old friends meeting.

The kitchen holds up its end. The Venetian Chicken comes tender and juicy with mushrooms and sautéed vegetables. The lasagna carries Italian sausage with balanced heat, and the Tuscany Platter puts several dishes on one plate for the undecided. Start with fried ravioli, and expect warm bread with garlic in olive oil before anything else arrives.

Practical notes: Mario's is busy most weekends and seating is limited, so a reservation is the safe move. Servers know the wine list, and a carafe of house wine is the value pour. The classic pasta dishes are the most reliable orders.

Insider tip

Mario's stays busy on weekends and seating can be limited, so diners suggest making a reservation.

What to order

Venetian Chicken, Lasagna, Fried Ravioli

HoursMon - Thu: 5:00 PM - 9:30 PMFri - Sat: 5:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun: Closed
Address7916 S Broadway Ave, Ste 200
Tyler, TX 75703
Call Directions
Map showing Mario's Italian Restaurant© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Venetian Chicken

Tender, juicy chicken with mushrooms and sautu00e9ed vegetables, and diners call it some of the best chicken they have had.

Lasagna

Layers carry Italian sausage with real flavor and balanced heat, and diners pair it with salad and the house bread.

Fried Ravioli

A starter diners call exceptional alongside the calamari, and a good way to open the table before the platters.

Advertisement
02

Pit Stop Pizza

Pizza · Bullard · $$ · № 10 on the ListBack to filters

8.5Insider Score
Pit Stop PizzaYelp

Stuffed Crust Pizza in Bullard

Out on US Highway 69 North in Bullard, Pit Stop Pizza is the place families keep returning to, often several generations at one table. The stuffed crust pizza draws the most praise, with sauce diners call rich and toppings piled higher than at the chains. Thin crust and hand tossed are both on offer. The dinner salad is huge and comes with a homemade ranch, and cinnamon sticks close out the meal. Staff learn regulars by name.

Pit Stop Pizza on US Highway 69 North is the pizza house Bullard families treat as a weekly routine. Diners describe a crust that tastes homemade and buttery, a tomato sauce with more depth than the chains, and toppings that seem fresher than most. Stuffed crust is the order people name first, with the regular supreme a standout.

Thin crust, hand tossed and a cauliflower crust are all on the menu, and a gluten free pizza gets kind words from diners who need one. The dinner salad is large enough to share and comes with a homemade ranch that shows up in review after review. Buffalo and barbecue wings round out the table, and cinnamon sticks are the dessert kids remember.

Practical notes: Pit Stop takes cash or check only, so come prepared. Staff are known for remembering regulars and for handling big groups with ease. The delivery area is small, and several diners from farther south make the drive anyway.

Insider tip

Pit Stop takes cash or check only, so bring one, though diners say staff will hold an order while a guest runs to the ATM.

What to order

Stuffed Crust Pizza, Dinner salad with ranch, Cinnamon sticks

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Thu: 4:00 PM - 9:00 PMFri: 4:00 PM - 10:00 PMSat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address50579 US Hwy 69 N
Bullard, TX 75757
Call Directions
Map showing Pit Stop Pizza© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Stuffed Crust Pizza

Loaded with toppings, the supreme on a stuffed crust is the order diners point to first.

Dinner salad with ranch

Big enough to share with leftovers, it comes heaped with fresh vegetables and a homemade ranch diners rave about.

Cinnamon sticks

Soft and sweet like the best part of a cinnamon roll, they are the dessert kids ask for.

03

Topp's Pizza

Pizza · Tyler · № 18 on the ListBack to filters

8.2Insider Score
Topp's PizzaYelp

Carry-Out Pies on Shiloh Road

Topp's Pizza on Shiloh Road is a carry-out counter with a few chairs for waiting, and diners say the pies are worth the drive across town. Toppings run generous from edge to crust, and the sauce stays balanced rather than heavy. The Chicken Alfredo pizza and the thin crust pepperoni come up again and again, and half and half pies let a table try two specialties at once. Wings come up in 24 of 200 diner reviews, praised for their crunch.

Topp's Pizza on Shiloh Road is a small carry-out shop, and diners from across Tyler say they pass closer pizza places to get here. The draw is the toppings: pies come covered from corner to crust, with sauce kept light enough to let the sausage and pepperoni come through.

The Chicken Alfredo pizza is the specialty diners recommend most, with thick slices and a creamy white sauce. Thin crust fans praise a base that stays light and crispy without burning, and the thin crust pepperoni with jalapeños has a loyal group of regulars. Half and half pies let a table split two specialties, such as cheeseburger and meat lovers. The buffalo wings come out crunchy, and garlic sticks make a good side.

Practical notes: there is no dine-in seating, only a few chairs for waiting. Busy evenings can mean a long wait, so ordering ahead online is the smoother route. Parking is shared with a laundromat next door.

Insider tip

Topp's is takeout only and shares a strip with a laundromat, so order ahead online and expect a wait at busy dinner hours.

What to order

Chicken Alfredo Pizza, Thin crust pepperoni, Wings

HoursMon - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Address3101 Shiloh Rd, Ste 131
Tyler, TX 75707
Call Directions
Map showing Topp's Pizza© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Thick, hearty slices with a creamy white sauce, and a large one is hard for two people to finish.

Thin crust pepperoni

Light and crispy without being burnt, it is the crust regulars order with jalapeu00f1os on top.

Wings

Crunchy rather than wet, the buffalo wings go well with ranch, and diners often add a second order.

04

Top It Off Pizza

Pizza · TylerBack to filters

8.0Insider Score
Top It Off PizzaYelp

New York Slices on Loop 323

Top It Off Pizza sits on Loop 323 next to Poch's, and transplants from New York and New Jersey say its slices taste like home. The crust is thin and folds cleanly, the sauce is not too sweet, and pies are tossed by hand behind the counter. Garlic knots come up in 22 of 200 diner reviews, and the cannoli is the dessert to take home. The Texas size pie is big enough to feed a family twice.

Top It Off Pizza on Loop 323, next to Poch's, wins over the hardest crowd in town: diners who moved to East Texas from New York, New Jersey and Michigan. They describe a thin, foldable crust, a sauce that is not too sweet, and pies tossed by hand behind the counter while customers watch.

The pepperoni pie is the classic, and real sliced sausage gets special praise. The Bianca Verde and the Old Wilbur, loaded with ham, bacon, sausage and pepperoni, are the specialty picks. Garlic knots are soft and buttery under melted cheese and come with marinara. Cannoli made in house and a New York style cheesecake with strawberries close out the meal, and the fried mushrooms and calzones have their own fans.

Practical notes: the Texas size pie is huge, and one couple got two dinners from a single large. Toppings add up on the bill. The counter can feel brisk on a busy night, so arrive knowing the order.

Insider tip

The counter can be brisk at busy times, so know the order before stepping up, and consider the Texas size pie for leftovers.

What to order

New York style pizza, Garlic knots, Cannoli

HoursMon - Thu: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: Closed
Address1700 S Se Loop 323
Tyler, TX 75701
Call Directions

More about the dishes

New York style pizza

Thin and foldable with a good crust and real sliced sausage, it is the slice New York transplants come for.

Garlic knots

Soft, buttery and covered in melted cheese, they are best dipped in the marinara on the side.

Cannoli

Made in house in the traditional style, these are the treat families pick up on the way out.

05

Bella Italian Cafe Restaurant

Pizza · TylerBack to filters

7.7Insider Score
Bella Italian Cafe RestaurantYelp

Lobster Ravioli Off FM 2493

Bella Italian Cafe Restaurant on FM 2493, out toward Flint, is an Italian dining room first and a pizza stop second. Diners who order the pizza say it reminds them of eating in Italy, and the margarita pizza has its own fans. Most tables start with the Shrimp Cognac and move on to the Lobster Ravioli, the dish people talk about before they ever sit down. The room handles large family parties well.

Bella Italian Cafe is on FM 2493, out toward Flint, and diners send friends here for one dish in particular: the lobster ravioli. It is rich and tasty, and people who order it once tend to order it again, along with the veal dishes, which use real veal rather than a patty.

Start with the Shrimp Cognac, jumbo shrimp sautéed in a cognac cream sauce. Servers suggest soaking the garlic bread in the sauce, and some diners take extra sauce home. The garlic knots are made fresh and soft, and the Bella salad is a regular order, sometimes topped with grilled salmon. Save room for cannoli or tiramisu, the two desserts diners name.

Practical notes: Sunday lunch is a habit for regulars, and a reservation means little or no wait. Large parties have been seated promptly when they booked ahead. At lunch the ravioli portion runs on the smaller side, so add a starter for a hungry table.

Insider tip

A reservation means little or no wait, and larger groups have been seated promptly when they booked ahead.

What to order

Shrimp Cognac, Lobster Ravioli, Cannoli

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Thu: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address16700 Fm 2493, Ste 1800
Tyler, TX 75703
Call Directions
Map showing Bella Italian Cafe Restaurant© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Shrimp Cognac

Jumbo shrimp come in a cognac cream sauce, and servers suggest dipping the garlic bread right into it.

Lobster Ravioli

The plate people recommend by name, rich and tasty, though the lunch portion runs on the small side.

Cannoli

Diners call these a dessert not to skip, and some order tiramisu alongside for the table.

06

New York Pizza & Pasta

Italian · Tyler · $Back to filters

7.4Insider Score
New York Pizza & PastaYelp

Slices and Pasta on South Broadway

New York Pizza & Pasta on South Broadway sells big New York style slices by the piece, so a table can try a few before committing to a whole pie. The slice, salad and drink combo is a favorite midday deal, and lunch comes up in 14 of 200 diner reviews. Past the pizza, the eggplant parmigiana earns real loyalty, and garlic knots come out for dipping. Diners mention a spotless dining room and friendly counter staff.

New York Pizza & Pasta on South Broadway runs on counter service: order at the register under the overhead menu, and the food comes to the table. Diners describe the room as spotless and the staff as patient with first timers who need a minute with the menu.

Pizza is the reason to come. The crust is thin and buttery with a crisp bottom, the ingredients taste fresh, and the cheese pulls. Pizza by the slice lets newcomers try a few kinds before committing to a whole pie, and the meatball, spinach and Alfredo slice has its fans. On the pasta side, regulars recommend the eggplant parmigiana over any other in town, with chicken Tuscany close behind. Dip the garlic knots in marinara.

Practical notes: lunch is busy, and the slice, salad and drink combo is a popular deal. Gluten free pizza is on the menu. Street parking is sometimes needed at lunch. Check a takeout pizza before leaving, and the staff will fix any mistake.

Insider tip

Lunch is the popular time, and diners sometimes park on the street and walk around to the entrance.

What to order

Pizza by the Slice, Eggplant Parmigiana, Garlic Knots

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Sun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address1621 South Broadway
Tyler, TX 75701
Call Directions
Map showing New York Pizza & Pasta© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Pizza by the Slice

Thin, buttery crust with a crisp bottom, and buying by the slice lets diners sample before ordering a whole pie.

Eggplant Parmigiana

Fresh and well made, with regulars who recommend it over any other version in town.

Garlic Knots

Soft and garlicky, and diners say they are best dipped in the house marinara.

Pizza questions, answered.

What is the best pizza in Tyler?
Mario's Italian Restaurant on South Broadway Avenue tops the list. Diners praise a crust baked with a light char at the edges and generous toppings, served in a dining room with live dinner music and old Hollywood photos on the walls.
Where can I find good pizza near me in Tyler?
On the south side, Mario's Italian Restaurant and New York Pizza & Pasta both sit on South Broadway. Top It Off Pizza is on Loop 323, Topp's Pizza is on Shiloh Road, and Bella Italian Cafe is out on FM 2493 toward Flint.
Where is the best New York style pizza in Tyler?
Top It Off Pizza on Loop 323 is the pick. Diners who grew up in New York and New Jersey say its thin, foldable slices come closest to home. New York Pizza & Pasta on South Broadway is the other choice, with large slices sold one at a time.
Is there good pizza outside Tyler, in Bullard?
Yes. Pit Stop Pizza on US Highway 69 North in Bullard is a local favorite for stuffed crust pizza, a big dinner salad with homemade ranch, and cinnamon sticks. It takes cash or check only, so plan ahead.

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Maribel Cantu
Taquerias & Towns Editor

Maribel covers how Tyler eats on an ordinary Tuesday: the taquerias, the kolache counters, the family kitchens, and the rooms in the smaller towns nearby. Her lists begin with the review record and end with a recommendation you can use tonight.

A new place to try.

The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.